SKINROUTE — Hyper-Personalized AI Skin Health Platform

Closed Comedones: Causes and BHA vs Retinol Care

Published: 2026-05-04 · 10 min read

Summary: They don't turn red or inflamed, but that bumpy texture across the forehead, cheeks, and chin has a real name: closed comedones. SKINROUTE breaks down why…

Key Takeaway

Those small under-the-skin bumps are closed comedones (whiteheads) — a pore whose opening has sealed over dead skin while oil builds up underneath. The basics are salicylic acid (BHA) to help loosen buildup inside the pore, a lightweight non-comedogenic moisturizer, and thorough cleansing, kept up for 6–8 weeks or more.

  • Because the opening is sealed, forcing it out can damage the pore wall and turn it into a red, inflamed blemish
  • Start retinol at a low concentration every other day, and keep up sun protection while using it
  • Milia are a different kind of bump that everyday skincare isn't meant for, so talk to a dermatologist about those instead

They don't turn red or inflamed, but that bumpy texture across the forehead, cheeks, and chin has a real name: closed comedones. SKINROUTE breaks down why they form and the ingredients and routine that smooth them out.

What Are Closed Comedones?

A comedone is a pore clogged with oil and dead skin — the stage before it turns into a red, inflamed blemish. When the pore opening seals shut over the clog, the trapped oil pushes up as a small skin-colored to whitish bump — that's what people mean by closed comedones (whiteheads). When the opening stays open over the clog, the contents look dark from the outside, which is a blackhead (open comedone).

Whiteheads vs. Blackheads

Closed Comedone (Whitehead)Open Comedone (Blackhead)
Pore openingSealed shutOpen
What it looks likeSmall skin-colored to whitish bumpDark-looking pore
Common spotsForehead, cheeks, chinNose and around the nose
Why it looks darkN/ANot dirt — it's the pore's contents reacting with air
Care basicsSalicylic acid, no rubbingSalicylic acid, no rubbing

Closed comedones don't hurt on their own, but leaving them alone or forcing them out lets bacteria build up in the pore, which can turn them into a red, inflamed blemish. That's why it helps to start caring for them while the bump is still small.

Why Closed Comedones Form

1. Dead skin builds up at the pore opening

When dead skin at a pore opening doesn't shed on schedule and piles up, the opening narrows and seals over. This also happens more easily on skin that's dry or sheds unevenly.

2. You're using pore-clogging products

Heavy oils, balm textures, or ingredients prone to clogging pores (comedogenic) can trigger closed comedones. If they increased after you started a new product, suspect that product first.

3. Cleansing falls short

Sunscreen and makeup left on the skin mix with oil and dead skin and clog pores. This happens more easily on days you wear a heavy-duty water-resistant sunscreen or full coverage base, since those need more thorough cleansing.

4. Hair, hair products, and friction

If closed comedones cluster on your forehead specifically, look at your bangs, hair products like wax or oil, and friction from a hat band. The forehead is where these factors touch skin most often.

Ingredients That Smooth Out Closed Comedones

Ingredients for Closed Comedones

Salicylic acid (BHA)
Oil-soluble, helps loosen oil and dead skin inside the pore
Retinol
Supports cell turnover so dead skin doesn't build up (start low-concentration, every other day)
Niacinamide
Balances oil and smooths texture

Salicylic Acid (BHA)

Salicylic acid is an oil-soluble ingredient widely used in products for clogged pores. For blackheads and whiteheads, the AAD's acne guide points first to a retinoid to unclog pores, and says to give it six to eight weeks. Start with a toner or serum 2–3 times a week, and increase frequency if there's no stinging. A leave-on exfoliant is gentler on skin than a gritty scrub.

Retinol

Retinol is a vitamin A derivative that supports skin's turnover cycle so dead skin doesn't build up at the pore opening. The AAD advises starting retinol every other day and increasing frequency as skin adjusts. Apply it in the evening only, and be thorough with sunscreen the next morning while using it. At first, alternate nights with salicylic acid rather than layering them on the same night to keep irritation down. Talk to a dermatologist about whether you need a stronger retinoid. The AAD says retinoids should not be used during pregnancy, so if you're pregnant, planning to be, or breastfeeding, talk to a doctor before starting retinol. For how to start using retinol, see The Beginner's Guide to Retinol.

Light Moisturizing

Even with closed comedones, skin still needs moisture. The AAD advises moisturizing acne-prone skin too, just with a non-comedogenic product. Skin tends to dry out more while using salicylic acid or retinol, which makes moisturizing even more important. A gel or lotion texture is lighter than a heavy cream.

Thorough but Gentle Cleansing

On days with heavy sunscreen or makeup, double cleanse to remove residue — but washing more than three times a day or scrubbing hard just adds irritation.

BHA vs Retinoid for Closed Comedones

Both ingredients are common choices for clogged pores, but they work in different ways. Retinoids are what the AAD points to first for whiteheads. BHA is a gentler, oil-soluble option, and many routines alternate the two on different nights.

Salicylic acid (BHA)RetinolStronger retinoids
How it helpsOil-soluble, works inside the pore to loosen oil and dead skinSupports skin turnover so dead skin is less likely to build upAct on the same turnover process with more strength
How to startA few nights a week, then increase if skin stays comfortableEvery other night, building up slowlyUnder a dermatologist's guidance
Common side effectsDryness, stingingDryness, peeling, irritation, sun sensitivityDryness, peeling, irritation, sun sensitivity
Where you get itOver the counterOver the counterUsually through a dermatologist; availability varies by country
Good fit forSkin that wants a gentler startSteady, long-term routines with daytime sunscreenStubborn bumps after a dermatologist's advice

A benzoyl peroxide wash is the other ingredient the AAD's acne guide mentions for whiteheads and blackheads.

The Basic Closed Comedone Routine

The Basic Closed Comedone Routine

  1. Cleanse — A mild, low-pH cleanser at night, double cleansing only on heavy sunscreen or makeup days
  2. Exfoliate — A salicylic acid toner or serum, starting 2–3 times a week
  3. Retinol — Every other day, on nights you skip salicylic acid
  4. Moisturize — A non-comedogenic gel or lotion, every day
  5. Sunscreen — Every morning, a lightweight formula

Add new ingredients one at a time. Give skin 2–3 weeks to adjust to salicylic acid before adding retinol — spacing them out this way makes it easier to tell what's causing irritation if it shows up.

Should You Pop Closed Comedones?

It's best not to. The AAD advises that popping acne yourself raises the risk of scarring and dark marks. Because the opening on a closed comedone is sealed, pressing on it with fingers or a tool tends to damage the pore wall rather than push the contents out, which can turn it into a red, inflamed blemish. It's safer to leave it alone and keep up a gentle routine with salicylic acid and retinol instead. See Should You Pop a Pimple? for more on handling the urge to pop.

Closed Comedones — Do This, Avoid That

✓ Do

  • Keep up salicylic acid and retinol for 6–8 weeks or more
  • A lightweight, non-comedogenic moisturizer
  • Keep bangs and hair products off your forehead
  • Add new ingredients one at a time

✕ Avoid

  • Squeezing with fingers or a tool
  • Scrubbing hard with grit or a towel
  • Heavy oils or balm textures
  • Starting several active ingredients all at once

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to see a difference in closed comedones?

For whiteheads and blackheads, the AAD's acne guide suggests allowing six to eight weeks before judging whether what you're using is working. Right after starting retinol, it can look like more bumps are surfacing at first — if that lasts a long time or turns red and stinging, it may be a sign the product doesn't agree with you. See Retinol Purging vs. a Bad Reaction for how to tell the difference.

Are closed comedones the same as milia?

No. Milia are small white bumps made of dead skin trapped in a tiny sac — they're firmer than closed comedones and tend to show up around the eyes. Everyday skincare isn't meant for them, so talk to a dermatologist if you want them removed.

Why do I only get closed comedones on my forehead?

Hair wax or oil, friction from bangs, and hat bands are common culprits. Keep hair products off your face, and try cutting down the time your bangs spend covering your forehead.

Can I use a scrub on closed comedones?

It's not recommended. The AAD advises against rubbing acne-prone skin. A leave-on exfoliant like salicylic acid is gentler on skin than a gritty scrub.

Is BHA or retinol better for closed comedones?

Neither is best for everyone. The AAD's acne guide points first to a retinoid to unclog pores. Retinol is a milder retinoid found in cosmetics, while stronger retinoids are a conversation with a dermatologist. Salicylic acid is a gentler, oil-soluble option. Many people alternate them on different nights.

What does the AAD say about retinoids for closed comedones?

The AAD's acne guide points first to a retinoid to unclog pores and says it may take six to eight weeks to see a change. Retinol in cosmetics is a milder relative; talk to a dermatologist about stronger options. Start slowly and use sunscreen during the day.

Find What's Causing Your Closed Comedones

Closed comedones come from products, cleansing habits, and hairstyle choices that differ from person to person. SKIN100 Precision Skin Analysis uses over 100 survey questions to analyze 8 core factors — lifestyle habits, skincare habits, external environment, and more — to flag the habits clogging your pores, and your AI coach guides you through the order and routine of ingredients to match your results.

References

  1. American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) — How to treat different types of acne
  2. American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) — Retinoid or retinol?
  3. American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) — Moisturizer: Why you may need it if you have acne
  4. American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) — Pimple popping: Why only a dermatologist should do it
  5. Reynolds RV, et al. Guidelines of care for the management of acne vulgaris. J Am Acad Dermatol 2024

Related Entries

Medical Disclaimer

SKINROUTE is not a medical device or healthcare provider. All content is general skincare information for reference only. If you have concerns about your skin, please consult a board-certified dermatologist.