Key Takeaway
What's left after acne clears can show up as red marks, brown marks, or pitted scars, and each has a different cause and calls for different care. Red and brown marks tend to fade over time with sun protection and gentle care, but pitted scars can't be filled in with a topical product and call for a dermatologist's opinion.
- If the color fades briefly when you press on it, it's likely a red mark; if it stays the same, it's more likely a brown mark
- Daily sun protection, regardless of weather, is the foundation of caring for any kind of mark
- Popping pimples or picking at scabs raises the risk of darker marks and scarring
Everything left behind after acne clears can look like a "scar," but it actually falls into two groups: marks, where only the surface color has changed, and scars, where the tissue itself has caved in. SKINROUTE breaks down how to tell the types apart, what you can do at home for each, and when it's time to see a dermatologist.
The 3 Kinds of Marks Left After Acne
What's left after acne generally falls into three types: red marks, brown marks, and pitted scars. Red and brown marks are flat, with only the color different from the rest of your skin, while pitted scars are where the tissue underneath has caved in, leaving a dip on the surface. It's common to have more than one type on the same face, so figuring out which kind each mark is comes first.
Red Marks vs. Brown Marks vs. Pitted Scars
| Red Marks | Brown Marks | Pitted Scars | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appearance | A flat red or pink mark | A flat brown or dark reddish mark | A dip in the skin's surface |
| Cause | Small blood vessels that stay dilated after acne | Melanin that builds up after acne | Dermal tissue damaged by deep acne |
| When you press lightly | Color briefly fades | Color stays the same | The dip stays the same |
| Over time | Usually fades gradually | Fades gradually, sometimes over many months | Rarely fills in on its own |
| What you can do at home | Soothing care and sun protection | Brightening ingredients and sun protection | Preventing new scars, seeing a dermatologist |
Red Marks — Left by Blood Vessels
A red mark (post-inflammatory erythema) is what's left when the small blood vessels that dilated during an inflamed pimple stay dilated. Since melanin isn't the cause, brightening ingredients alone can be slow to make a difference — soothing skin and cutting down on irritation matters more.
Try pressing lightly on the mark with your finger or a clear glass. If the redness fades while you're pressing and comes back once you let go, it's likely a red mark.
Caring for Red Marks
- Keep applying moisturizers with soothing ingredients like centella (cica) and panthenol.
- Cut back on things that easily flush your face, like hot water, saunas, and scrubbing while cleansing.
- Sun exposure can make redness linger longer, so wear sunscreen every day.
Brown Marks — Left by Melanin
A brown mark is post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation — the result of skin producing extra melanin after going through the redness of a pimple. It tends to be darker and longer-lasting on deeper skin tones. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) advises addressing what caused the mark in the first place (acne, irritation) and staying consistent to fade dark spots.
Caring for Brown Marks
- If new pimples keep appearing, new marks will too, so managing your acne comes first.
- Bring in brightening ingredients like niacinamide, vitamin C, or alpha-arbutin one at a time, and give each at least a few weeks of consistent use.
- Visible light can darken pigment too, so the AAD recommends a tinted sunscreen containing iron oxide.
You can find more on individual brightening ingredients in Caring for Different Types of Hyperpigmentation.
Ingredients Commonly Used for Marks
- Niacinamide
- Evens out redness and tone, relatively gentle
- Centella (Cica)
- Soothes redness
- Vitamin C
- Helps reduce melanin production, an antioxidant
- Alpha-Arbutin
- Reduces the activity of enzymes that make melanin
- Sunscreen
- The basic step for keeping marks from getting darker
Pitted Scars — Where Tissue Has Caved In
Pitted scars form when a deep, badly swollen pimple damages the dermal tissue underneath, and the skin doesn't fill back in properly. The AAD explains that the deeper and more painful the pimple, and the more it's popped or picked at, the higher the risk of scarring. You can find more detail in the Acne Scars and Marks encyclopedia entry.
Types of Scar Shapes
- Ice pick: Narrow at the opening and deep, like a puncture.
- Boxcar: Wide with sharply defined, box-like edges.
- Rolling: Gently sloped edges that give the skin a wave-like, uneven texture.
- Raised scars: The opposite — raised, thickened scars, often seen on the chest, back, shoulders, and jawline.
Because the tissue itself has caved in, a pitted scar can't be filled back in with a topical product like a cream or serum. What a dermatologist recommends depends on the scar's depth, shape, and extent, so if a scar bothers you, consult a dermatologist. What you can do at home is manage your acne to prevent new scars and use sun protection so the skin around a scar doesn't darken and make it stand out more.
Signs You Should See a Dermatologist
- A pitted scar has formed
- A scar is raised and thickened
- Deep, painful pimples keep recurring
- A mark hasn't changed after months of consistent care
- A mark's shape or color suddenly changes
Care Principles That Apply to Every Type of Mark
1. Sun Protection — Every Day
Both red and brown marks can get darker and last longer with sun exposure. The AAD recommends a broad-spectrum, SPF 30+, water-resistant sunscreen. Wear it daily, even on cloudy days, and reapply every 2 hours outdoors.
2. Don't Pop, Don't Pick
The AAD notes that popping pimples yourself raises the risk of scars and dark marks. Picking at a scab also re-irritates the same spot. What to do instead when you're tempted to pop is covered in Is It Ever Okay to Pop a Pimple?
3. Gentle and Consistent
Trying to fade a mark faster by scrubbing it or layering on several products at once can pile up irritation and make it darker instead. Cleanse gently with a mild cleanser without scrubbing, and try one ingredient at a time, consistently, for weeks to months.
Caring for Marks — Do This, Avoid That
✓ Do
- Sunscreen every day, regardless of weather
- Reapply every 2 hours outdoors
- Cleanse gently with a mild cleanser, without scrubbing
- One ingredient at a time, used consistently
✕ Avoid
- Popping pimples or picking at scabs
- Overusing scrubs and exfoliants
- Starting several brightening products at once
- Switching products after just a few weeks of no results
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I tell a red mark from a brown mark?
Press lightly with a finger or a clear glass. If the color briefly fades, it's likely a red mark from dilated blood vessels; if it stays the same, it's more likely a brown mark from melanin buildup. It's common to have a mix of both.
How long does it take for acne marks to fade?
It depends on the type of mark and your skin tone, and it can take several months or more. Skipping sun protection makes marks last longer, so if there's no change after months of consistent care, consult a dermatologist.
Can pitted scars be filled in at home?
No, a topical product can't fill in a pitted scar. The right approach depends on the scar's depth and shape, so it's more realistic to consult a dermatologist.
Is it okay to wear makeup over a mark?
Yes. Choose a non-comedogenic product that won't clog pores, and remove it gently at night without rubbing.
Find the Right Care for Your Skin
If marks keep coming back, it's worth looking at the habits behind your acne first. SKIN100 Precision Skin Analysis analyzes 8 core factors — lifestyle habits, skincare habits, external environment, and more — through over 100 survey questions to flag the habits affecting your acne and marks. If you just want a quick look at marks specifically, Skin Concern Solutions is a good place to start.
References
- American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) — Acne scars: Overview
- American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) — Pimple popping: Why only a dermatologist should do it
- American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) — How to fade dark spots in darker skin tones
- American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) — How to select a sunscreen